The Apprentice – Advertising
Monday, November 15th, 2010In recognition that the products of both teams were similar, let’s take a look at the campaigns of both teams from a strategic corporate image perspective.
Alex’s Team: The Germinator
Key Elements:
- Black bottle, a red label with the image of a tough female.
- Tag line: “It terminates germs and dirt”.
- Television ad: A little boy can use the Germinator to clean gravy better than a strong man, because he has the Germinator product.
Chris’s Team: Octi-kleen
Key Elements:
- Orange bottle and pastel label with the image of a smiling octopus.
- Tag line “Eight hands are better than two”.
- Television ad: A mum can clean the house like an octopus, very quickly, as if she had eight hands.
The scope of this task was very unrealistic, the teams had to create product packaging and two supporting ads. Unfortunately this Advertising task only asked the teams to consider a very limited scope of deliverables, and did not portray an integrated marketing cycle. Although product packaging is important and most products, especially new products, benefit from television and radio ads, neither team discussed a strategy, a potential target demographic or even a corporate image as a whole.
As well, neither team developed a great brand name. Some of the questions to be asked when developing a strong brand name (Cow and Baack, 1997 p. 40):
- What are the brand’s most compelling benefits?
- What emotions are elicited by the brand either during or after the purchase?
- What one word best describes the brand?
- What is important to consumers in the purchase of the product?
Neither team discussed the relative benefits of the brand in comparison with others, or even attempted to portray an amount of competitive advantage. The Germinator had packaging that made it appear as though it belonged in another aisle, but neither team had any idea of what their brand equity would be.
Neither team actually considered the needs or desires of the target audience. Considering that the majority of consumers who purchase cleaning products are female, neither product or campaign targeted females specifically. Alex’s Germinator was a very masculine looking product, and Chris’s Octi-kleen television advert was very old fashioned and focused on the man of the house relaxing while the wife cleans up with her eight hands.
Lord Sugar certainly imposed on the team that there is much more to an effective campaign than making a snappy commercial. As he used the Titanic movie as an example, it won many Oscars but it was a poor advertisement for a cruise ship.
Ultimately, the critical failure of the Germinator was that the goal of the use of the product in the television commercial was to clean gravy, whose core function does not match with the name Germinator. Considering that a product is the most critical component of a campaign, the Germinator name was ill suited to a product that removed stains and removed kitchen grime.
Overall we were very disappointed by the efforts and results of the advertising task!




